LAST DAY!! Stop in to visit and say goodbye for the season

George Urban

Frosty's Ice Cream buildings
Closing Sunday October 1st
Fall Hours : 12:00 - 9:00pm
2424 George Urban Blvd.
Depew, NY 14043
(716) 866-5899


Frosty's Ice Cream buildings
Closing Monday October 9th
Fall Hours: 12:00-9:00pm
5500 Broadway St.
Lancaster, NY 14086
(716) 866-5899


  • Signature Warm Brownie Sundae

Top Menu Items

  • Real Custard
  • 75+ Different Shakes
  • 100's of Arctics
  • 30+ Perry's Flavors
  • Fresh Fruits
  • Homemade Brownies
  • 1lb. Large Cone
  • Huge Sizes
  • Doggie Delights
  • Ice Cream Cakes

The One Pounder

One Pound Ice Cream Cone

Frosty's is home to the one pound ice cream cone. It measures in at a whopping 14 inches tall!

This is available in hard ice cream and soft serve custard.

Frosty’s Colossal Cone Challenge

Cone Challenge Winners


Team Discount

Bring your team in after a game or practice and take advantage of Frosty's Team Discount.

First Time: 15% off
Second Time: 20% off
Every Time After: 25% off

Cake Discount

Join our Cake Club for discounts
See Cake Page

Welcome to Frosty's

The dream started April 1st in 2003 at 5500 Broadway in Lancaster NY, and we have been family owned and operated ever since. For 15 years we have been serving delicious ice cream with a smile.

We have a very family friendly atmosphere, where you always see someone you know. It's where families come together and friends are made.

In 2011 Frosty's ice cream expanded adding a second location to better serve the Lancaster and Depew area. This location is at 2424 George urban Blvd. in Depew and Cheektowaga. Like our Broadway location, this location serves all the same quality products, huge sizes, and wide varieties. We continue to have fun as we serve the loyal following of customers in the Lancaster and Depew area. Nothing beats a Frosty's ice cream on a summer day.

Crazy Hats

Over the years our loyal customers have brought us in funny hats. Our collection has now reached over 120 unique Hats

crazy hat collection

Donate a CRAZY HAT and receive a free ice cream!

Family Owned

David, Nicholas & Kristy Del Carlo

Made with a personal touch!

Frosty's Banana Split

Top Quality Brands

Perry's logo Upstate Farm logo Joy Cones logo Turkey Hill logo
WOW Cow logo Itti Bitz logo Pepsi logo Hershey's logo