Specialty Items

Warm Brownie Sundae

Warm Brownie Sundae

Real Vanilla Custard topped with our homemade warm double chocolate brownies, smothered with Hot Fudge, and topped with whip cream, and nuts.

Fluffer Nutter Crunch Sundae

Fluffer Nutter Crunch Sundae

Real vanilla custard topped with creamy peanut butter, marshmallow, crushed butterfingers, whip cream and nuts.

Salted Caramel Pretzel Sundae

Salted Caramel Pretzel Sundae

Real vanilla custard topped with warm caramel fudge, crushed pretzels, lightly sprinkled sea salt, whip cream and nuts

Peanut Butter Explosion Sundae

Peanut Butter Explosion

Real vanilla custard topped with real peanut butter, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and Reese's Pieces.

Red Velvet Cake Arctic

Red Velvet Arctic

Real Vanilla Custard blended with Red Velvet Cake Mix and chocolate sprinkles. Take Red Velvet to a new high.

Warm Caramel Apple Sundae

Caramel Apple Sundae

Real Vanilla Custard topped with Caramel, WarmCinnamon Apple pie filling, whipped cream, nuts and cherry.

Frosty’s Doggie Delights

Frosty's Doggie Delight

Don’t forget your furry friend. A special blend with actually dog treats

Loganberry Milkshakes

Loganberry Milkshake

One of WNY Staples

Dirt and Worm Sundae

Dirt and Worms Sundae

Real Vanilla Custard topped with crushed Oreo’s, Gummy Worms, and Whipped Cream. (Add some Hershey’s syrup to make your sundae muddy)

Pop Rocks or Pez
Arctic and Sundae

Nutter Butter Sundae

Cracker Jack Arctic and Sundae

Nutella Pretzel Sundae

Real vanilla custard with caramel corn, spanish peanuts and caramel fudge

Cookie Monster Arctic

Cookie monster Arctic

Real Vanilla Custard blended together with chocolate chip cookies and crushed Oreo’s.

Cotton Candy Crunch Arctic

Cotton Candy Arctic

Real Vanilla Custard blended with cotton candy crunch pieces and cotton candy dip topping. Taste like the real thing.

Smore's Arctic or Sundae

Smore's Arctic or Sundae

Hershey’s Chocolate, Graham Crackers and Marshmallows.

Real Fruit Fizzy’s

Fizzy's

Frosty’s own creation. Perry's Lemon Sorbet blended with your choice of real fruit and a dash of Sierra Mist. A refreshing blend on a warm day!

Chocolate Covered Pretzel Arctic

Chocolate Covered Pretzel Arctic

Real vanilla custard blended with Crunchy Pretzels and chocolate dip topping.

Banana Split

2 sizes - Rowboat and Yacht

Banana Split